United Kingdom: ESG Regulatory Update – Code of Conduct for ESG data and ratings providers

In brief

On 22 November 2022, the FCA announced the formation of a new ESG data and ratings group, which will work to develop a Code of Conduct for Environmental Social and Governance (ESG) data and ratings providers.


The proposed Code originates in the FCA's Feedback Statement (FS22/4), published following its consultation on climate-related disclosures by standard listed companies (CP21/18). This consultation highlighted that there is an active debate in the market around the role and regulatory oversight of ESG providers. In its Feedback Statement, the FCA noted that the conclusions reached by ESG ratings and rating-like products providers should not be a source of harm, as long as the providers: 

  • Are transparent about their methodology, information, and data inputs.
  • Determine their outputs by applying systematic processes, and sound systems and controls.
  • Identify, manage, and disclose conflicts of interest.
  • Operate with robust governance standards. 

The regulator's concern, however, is that some of these conditions may not be fully met in practice, thereby causing potential damage to the wider market. These risks are exacerbated by the fact that firms are beginning to embed ESG data and ratings products into their investment processes with ever-increasing frequency, which in turn influences capital allocation decisions.

Stop-gap measure?

Although the UK Government is considering whether to bring ESG data and ratings providers within scope of the FCA's supervisory perimeter, adoption of the legislative measures necessary to achieve this will take some time. For that reason, the FCA appears to be approaching the Code as an interim, voluntary measure prior to implementation of any new legislative regime.

What will the Code of Conduct look like?

There is as yet limited information on what the Code will look like. The FCA has, however, described it as "a comprehensive, proportionate and ambitious set of best practices", and noted that it will be structured around four key outcomes:

  1. Transparency
  2. Good governance
  3. Robust systems and controls
  4. Sound management of conflicts of interest

As noted, the Code will be voluntary only at the outset, and it remains to be seen what the take-up will be amongst ESG data providers.

Asset class focus

The Code appears intended to cover a range of asset classes, and it is notable that both LSEG and ICMA will be involved in taking the initiative forward. This will come as good news for many in the market, given concerns around patchy ESG data in the fixed-income markets.

International and EU angle

The aim is for the Code to promote global consistency. The FCA has therefore stressed that it will take into account not only international recommendations from IOSCO on ESG rating and data providers but also developments in individual jurisdictions such as Japan and the EU. Earlier this year, for instance, we saw ESMA published the outcome of its Call for Evidence on Market Characteristics of ESG Rating and Data Providers, which is intended to feed into a broader EU push to regulate ESG data providers. The FCA will likely be watching the EU's developing framework closely.

Commercial considerations and next steps

The FCA's proposed Code is likely to be welcomed by the increasing number of firms that rely on external ESG data providers. The emphasis on transparency around the methodology for setting ESG ratings is helpful, given concerns in the market that individual ESG providers can reach varying conclusions depending on data inputs and differing degrees of emphasis on ESG criteria. ESMA has previously stressed, for example, that the majority of ESG ratings users typically contract with several providers simultaneously, in order to receive different types of ESG assessments. It can be challenging for firms to navigate between the differing approaches of ratings firms in practice.

Once the Code is published, regulated firms should review which of their providers are signatories to it, or agree to comply with it on a public or contractual basis.

From the perspective of ESG data providers themselves, the Code may form a "soft" introduction to operating in a more regulated, transparent environment prior to the introduction of UK legislation. It also represents an opportunity for providers to enter into a dialogue with the FCA around the challenges of putting together ESG ratings in circumstances where underlying data is poor quality or challenging to obtain.

Copyright © 2024 Baker & McKenzie. All rights reserved. Ownership: This documentation and content (Content) is a proprietary resource owned exclusively by Baker McKenzie (meaning Baker & McKenzie International and its member firms). The Content is protected under international copyright conventions. Use of this Content does not of itself create a contractual relationship, nor any attorney/client relationship, between Baker McKenzie and any person. Non-reliance and exclusion: All Content is for informational purposes only and may not reflect the most current legal and regulatory developments. All summaries of the laws, regulations and practice are subject to change. The Content is not offered as legal or professional advice for any specific matter. It is not intended to be a substitute for reference to (and compliance with) the detailed provisions of applicable laws, rules, regulations or forms. Legal advice should always be sought before taking any action or refraining from taking any action based on any Content. Baker McKenzie and the editors and the contributing authors do not guarantee the accuracy of the Content and expressly disclaim any and all liability to any person in respect of the consequences of anything done or permitted to be done or omitted to be done wholly or partly in reliance upon the whole or any part of the Content. The Content may contain links to external websites and external websites may link to the Content. Baker McKenzie is not responsible for the content or operation of any such external sites and disclaims all liability, howsoever occurring, in respect of the content or operation of any such external websites. Attorney Advertising: This Content may qualify as “Attorney Advertising” requiring notice in some jurisdictions. To the extent that this Content may qualify as Attorney Advertising, PRIOR RESULTS DO NOT GUARANTEE A SIMILAR OUTCOME. Reproduction: Reproduction of reasonable portions of the Content is permitted provided that (i) such reproductions are made available free of charge and for non-commercial purposes, (ii) such reproductions are properly attributed to Baker McKenzie, (iii) the portion of the Content being reproduced is not altered or made available in a manner that modifies the Content or presents the Content being reproduced in a false light and (iv) notice is made to the disclaimers included on the Content. The permission to re-copy does not allow for incorporation of any substantial portion of the Content in any work or publication, whether in hard copy, electronic or any other form or for commercial purposes.