Singapore: Successful opposition to a request for a qualification to geographical indication application by Consorzio del Formaggio Parmigiano Reggiano

In brief

Fonterra Co-operative Group Limited ("Requester") filed a request for qualification in respect of the registered Geographical Indication No. 50201900057U for "Parmigiano Reggiano" for "cheese" ("Registered GI"), which was filed in the name of Consorzio del Formaggio Parmigiano Reggiano ("Opponent"). The request was filed on the sole basis that the term "Parmesan" is not a translation of the Registered GI. 

The registrar allowed the opposition. 
 


Contents

In more detail 

Under the Geographical Indications Act 2014, protection is extended to the translations of registered geographical indications. If third parties have issues relating to any possible translations of geographical indications, they can file a request for qualification, which is similar to an opposition hearing. 

The Requester filed the request for qualification on only one basis, that "Parmesan" is not a translation of the Registered GI. Notably, the Requester did not plead that the term "Parmesan" is generic. 

The registrar found that the Opponent discharged its burden of proof that "Parmesan" is a translation of the Registered GI. In coming to this conclusion, the registrar agreed with the Opponent that the critical issue is the translation of "Parmigiano Reggiano" in Italian to "Parmesan" in English. The Opponent relied on the dictionary meaning of "Parmigiano Reggiano," which is defined as "another name for Parmesan cheese" in English according to the Collins Dictionary. 

Further, the registrar held that whether a term or phrase is a translation does not depend on how the terms are used in the marketplace. In this case, the wide variety of "Parmesan" cheese products available in the market is irrelevant to the ground that the Requester pleaded. 

Key takeaway

This decision highlights the importance of pleadings, and that parties should ensure that their supporting evidence matches the corresponding grounds of pleadings. It is imperative to consider what grounds to plead, the prospects of success under each ground and what to include in the pleadings to support each ground.

The Requester's evidence attempted to show the broad range of "Parmesan" cheese products, which may be relevant if the pleaded ground was that "Parmesan" is or has become generic. However, as the Requester only confined its pleadings to the ground on translation, the registrar did not need to consider the issue of whether "Parmesan" is generic. 
 

* * * * *

LOGO_Wong&Leow_Singapore

© 2022 Baker & McKenzie.Wong & Leow. All rights reserved. Baker & McKenzie.Wong & Leow is incorporated with limited liability and is a member firm of Baker & McKenzie International, a global law firm with member law firms around the world. In accordance with the common terminology used in professional service organizations, reference to a "principal" means a person who is a partner, or equivalent, in such a law firm. Similarly, reference to an "office" means an office of any such law firm. This may qualify as "Attorney Advertising" requiring notice in some jurisdictions. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.


Copyright © 2024 Baker & McKenzie. All rights reserved. Ownership: This documentation and content (Content) is a proprietary resource owned exclusively by Baker McKenzie (meaning Baker & McKenzie International and its member firms). The Content is protected under international copyright conventions. Use of this Content does not of itself create a contractual relationship, nor any attorney/client relationship, between Baker McKenzie and any person. Non-reliance and exclusion: All Content is for informational purposes only and may not reflect the most current legal and regulatory developments. All summaries of the laws, regulations and practice are subject to change. The Content is not offered as legal or professional advice for any specific matter. It is not intended to be a substitute for reference to (and compliance with) the detailed provisions of applicable laws, rules, regulations or forms. Legal advice should always be sought before taking any action or refraining from taking any action based on any Content. Baker McKenzie and the editors and the contributing authors do not guarantee the accuracy of the Content and expressly disclaim any and all liability to any person in respect of the consequences of anything done or permitted to be done or omitted to be done wholly or partly in reliance upon the whole or any part of the Content. The Content may contain links to external websites and external websites may link to the Content. Baker McKenzie is not responsible for the content or operation of any such external sites and disclaims all liability, howsoever occurring, in respect of the content or operation of any such external websites. Attorney Advertising: This Content may qualify as “Attorney Advertising” requiring notice in some jurisdictions. To the extent that this Content may qualify as Attorney Advertising, PRIOR RESULTS DO NOT GUARANTEE A SIMILAR OUTCOME. Reproduction: Reproduction of reasonable portions of the Content is permitted provided that (i) such reproductions are made available free of charge and for non-commercial purposes, (ii) such reproductions are properly attributed to Baker McKenzie, (iii) the portion of the Content being reproduced is not altered or made available in a manner that modifies the Content or presents the Content being reproduced in a false light and (iv) notice is made to the disclaimers included on the Content. The permission to re-copy does not allow for incorporation of any substantial portion of the Content in any work or publication, whether in hard copy, electronic or any other form or for commercial purposes.